Consciousness is the state of awareness of oneself, allowing us to be aware of our own existence and of everything that happens around us. It is the song that sticks in our head or the smell of the earth after the rain. The origin and nature of these experiences have been a mystery since early antiquity and the subject of many different philosophical and scientific theories.
Plato believed that there had to be realities that existed beyond the material world, which he called “the Forms”, and that human beings have an ability to grasp these forms, the soul or mind. He defined consciousness as the relationship of the soul with itself. Aristotle considered that in the composite of body (matter) and soul (form) that is the living being, consciousness is what completes and perfects it: “the soul neither exists without a body nor is it a body of some sort”.[1] In classical metaphysics, the idea of the existence of a soul remained for centuries until the emergence of mechanistic materialism in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries changed our approach to understanding the world and ourselves.
The materialist conception
The current conception of materialism holds that mental states are identical to brain states, and that our thoughts and feelings and our sense of self are properties of electrochemical activity in the brain. According to Francis Crick, co-discoverer of the structure of DNA, “[y]ou, your joys and your sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of personal identity and free will, are in fact nothing more than the behaviour of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated molecules”.[2]
Quantum behavior points to a change in direction
The twentieth century has led to a paradigm shift for the brain-mind problem. In the past, all the ideas generated and debated were merely theoretical speculations. Very little was known about the functioning of the brain and Newtonian mechanics cannot explain how the brain is able to generate unobservable conscious experiences. All speculations shifted into the realm of philosophy. However, the last century has seen significant progress in neuroscience, and quantum mechanics has revealed the behavior of matter at its most elementary levels, enabling a collaborative approach between science and philosophy to our knowledge of the mind.
Experimental research has opened up new avenues that allow us to better understand the nature and characteristics of this relationship between the brain and the mind. Different types of research appear to suggest the existence of a mind or soul independent of the brain and, in general, of the human body itself. These include observations of brain behavior reported by neurosurgeons, analysis of near-death experiences (NDE), analysis of terminal lucidity, and intelligence studies in hydrocephalic patients. It should be said that many of the most prominent neuroscientists of the twentieth century, including Charles Sherrington, Ramón y Cajal, Wilder Penfield, Benjamin Libet, Roger Sperry and John Eccles have been dualists, i.e., they have perceived a distinct nature and a differentiated existence of the mind with respect to the brain.
Observations of brain behavior by neuroscientists
There are many neuroscientists whose experiences have led them to conclude that there is something in humans that goes beyond matter. One such early notable example is that of Wilder Penfield, one of the neurosurgeons who pioneered corpus callostomy for epilepsy patients, and the observations he made in the numerous cases he treated in the course of his long career.
“First, he noticed something about seizures. He could cause seizures by stimulating the brain. A patient would jerk his arm, or feel tingling, or see flashes of light, or even have memories. But what he could never do was cause an intellectual seizure: the patient would never reason when his brain was stimulated”.
“Second, Penfield noted that patients always knew that the movement or sensation elicited by brain stimulation was done to them, but not by them. […] There was a part of the patient — the will — that Penfield could not reach with his electrode”. Consequently, he concluded that intellect and will do not come from the brain.[4]
Near death experiences (NDE)
Following a cardiac arrest, drowning, or major trauma, people often suffer a severe lack of oxygen. This causes a gradual reduction in the electrical activity in the brain, resulting in a “shutdown” of higher brain functioning, as well as most lower brain functions, a phenomenon characterized by a flat electroencephalogram (EEG).
Since the 1960s, advances in resuscitation have helped revive millions of people after their hearts have stopped. In a consensus statement made by 18 researchers from 13 different institutions, universities and large hospitals in the United States and Great Britain, published in the Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, the authors report that “[t]hese survivors have described a unique set of recollections in relation to death that appear universal”.[5]
Following the publication in 1975 of psychiatrist and physician Raymond A. Moody’s book Life After Life, in which he details accounts of patients with NDEs (coining the term with which these studies have been known since), a growing number of researchers began to collect qualitative data and research on these experiences.
To describe the generic case, the first thing to emphasize is that these are people who at that time are clinically dead, with a flat EEG, no brain stem function, and no electrical activity in the cerebral cortex or basic functions (such as the pupil’s response to light) that arise from the brain stem. In other words, all brain functions have ceased. This means that the patient cannot think, see, recall past memories, or remember new information. However, after the process of “resuscitation” they report that, at that time, their consciousness left their physical body (as a spirit or soul), and that this soul has the ability to think, see, hear, remember and move, without being constrained by physical laws.
The systematic studies conducted by renowned university hospitals throughout the world define a series of common characteristics of the phenomena experienced individually by the thousands of people analyzed. Patients who do not have significant brain functions say they are able to think, see, remember, and move. The perceptions of people who have experienced an NDE are very diverse, and therefore to systematize the research, it has been proposed that they be classified into 50 different themes.[6] However, in order to understand the mind-brain relationship discussed herein, two characteristics mentioned by these patients are important: the out-of-body experience, the perception that one is outside one’s own body; and both specific visual and auditory awareness. This is because it suggests that the mind or soul appears to be something connected to the brain or body but not by any mechanical, chemical, or electrical means.
Terminal lucidity studies
Over the past 250 years, physicians have sporadically documented an unusual increase in mental clarity in the last minutes, hours, or days before a patient’s death. Many of the cases described involve “patients with severe neurological disorders (such as advanced Alzheimer’s, advanced dementia, and severe neurological damage from strokes), having almost no cognitional capacity ability attributable to brain function, who suddenly awaken to consciousness and significant cognitional activity prior to death”.
A well-known example is explained by Ted Christopher[7] as follows: “Perhaps the most striking case involved a severely disabled young woman named Anna (‘Kathe’) Katherina Ehmer. Her case occurred in 1922 and had substantial verification as Kathe was a patient in a mental hospital and her episode of sudden lucidity was observed by the hospital’s chief physician Wilhem Wittneben and also its director Friedrich Happich. Kathe had been born with severe disabilities and as such had never spoken and moreover appeared detached from her environment. And yet in her last half-hour of life she somehow reportedly sung […], and in particular, this involved the repeated phrase, ‘Where does the soul find its home, its peace? Peace, peace, heavenly peace’.” Most cases are not so remarkable, but they conceal the same mystery: they seem to suggest a consciousness beyond the brain. A typical example was reported in the same article: “The case pertained to an elderly woman who had been sufficiently cognitively-detached for years that ‘she showed no sign of recognizing her daughter or anyone else’. Somehow, though, in the moments before she died ‘she started a normal conversation with her daughter’. The daughter was shocked and was left ‘utterly confused’”.[8]
German biologist Michael Nahm, who coined the term “terminal lucidity”, thinks “there are preliminary signs our minds somehow transcend our bodies, brains, even the physical realm altogether”, explaining that “[w]hen you see terminal lucidity in the context of all the other end-of-life experiences or near-death phenomena, they all seem to point to the fact that human consciousness is not tied to a one-to-one relation to the brain physiology”. [11]
Intelligence studies in hydrocephalic patients
Hydrocephalus is a condition in which cerebrospinal fluid replaces brain tissue in the vital parts of the brain needed for cognitive function. In 1980, British pediatrician John Lorber reported that some normal adults apparently cured of childhood hydrocephalus had no more than 5% of the normal brain tissue volume. Such extreme cases occurred in 60 of the 600 cases studied by Lorber. However, these were bafflingly normal children: they ate, drank, played, studied, and even excelled in class. One of the children with an extremely small brain of 5 mm even had a higher than normal IQ. This reality challenges all existing theories about the brain. In view of this fact, a large number of neurologists confine themselves to saying that we must alter our understanding of how the brain works. University of Sheffield neurologist Adrian Bower puts it this way: “There are still many questions to be answered about the human brain, and it has to be admitted that Lorber’s provocative approach does make you think about them”.[12] Given this evidence, other scientists, such as biochemist Donald R. Forsdyke of Queen’s University, are aiming in a new direction: “The brain [is] as a receptor/transmitter of some form of electromagnetic wave/particle… of course, when speaking of extracorporeal memory we enter the domain of ‘mind’ or ‘spirit’, with corresponding metaphysical implications.”[13]
In search of the physical explanation
A brain is conscious of an object when there is a physical representation (neural correlate) of that object in its memory along with its “meaning.” In classical physics, there is no mechanism that can explain how the brain generates the unobservable, inner psychological world of conscious experiences and how in turn those conscious experiences steer the underlying brain processes toward desired behavior. One of the unanswered questions is: how can a mental phenomenon that has no energy source give rise to an energy-dependent phenomenon?
Nevertheless, with the laws of quantum physics on unobservable quantum information, it does seem that the existence of the mind and its relationship with the brain can be explained. Very different theories based on these laws have been put forward, the one proposed by Bohm and Hiley being the one we understand that best responds to all the characteristics we know empirically of the mind-brain relationship.
Bohm’s explanation is based on quantum mechanics, on Louis de Broglie’s interpretation of “pilot wave”, in which he introduces some new ideas and a radically different view of nature, although it does not make any empirical difference.
In the words of Robert Spitzer, what Bohm proposes is “to conceive of matter not as a completely distinct substance from the mind (the soul) but rather as constituted by quantum fields that are intrinsic to particles influenced by space-time’s gravitational effects-and to conceive of quantum fields as the basic carrier of information fields that can influence particles and higher levels of information fields and physical systems”.[15]
Human thought and choice affect the quantum fields intrinsic to the elementary particles in the brain (and, through the brain, to the rest of the body). Consciousness emerges as an infinite sequence of quantum potentials at successive levels, each controlling the one below.
This mechanism by which individual consciousness can be abstracted from an underlying “background” consciousness constitutes an explanation of the mind-brain relationship that determines free conscious rational choice and satisfies experimental observations that point to a mind or soul outside the realm of classical physics.
Furthermore, as Hiley and Pylkkänen explain, “[b]y saying that information exists objectively (independently of the human mind) and plays an active organizing role at different levels of nature, we are proposing that we should radically change our world view.[16] Instead of saying that everything is fundamentally matter and energy, we follow Bohm in suggesting that reality is one process that has two sides: a somatic, material/energetic side and a significant, meaningful side”.[17]
One hundred years after the discovery of the quantum world, we can see how quantum mechanics is slowly bringing us closer to understanding reality. The explanation of consciousness is surely the greatest enigma that humanity has ever encountered. What has become known as an ontological interpretation of David Bohm’s quantum theory, which was published in 1952, allows an explanation in general terms of how the mind or soul might interact with the brain and, overall, with the human body. Through the counterintuitive laws arising from the quantum world we can come to understand the integrated hierarchy of mind-body.
Be that as it may, what may seem to us a surprising approach of science to the reality of the mind or soul would certainly have come as no surprise to Aristotle or Thomas Aquinas.
Manuel Ribes
Institute of Life Sciences – Bioethics Observatory
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
[1] García Alandete, J. Del alma y el intelecto en el De Anima de Aristóteles – Estudios Filosóficos, 63 (182), 23–45. (original published on 16/03/2021)
[2] George Stanciu Materialism: The False God of Modern Science – The Imaginative Conservative 1/03/2023
[3] Ibid.
[4] Michael Egnor Science and the Soul – Plough 20/08/2018
[5] Parnia, Sam, et al. Guidelines and standards for the study of death and recalled experiences of death – a multidisciplinary consensus statement and proposed future directions. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 2022, vol. 1511, no 1, p. 5-21.
[6] Ibid.
[7] Christopher, T. (2022) Dualism 101: Terminal Lucidity and an Explanation. Open Journal of Philosophy, 12, 687-700. doi: 10.4236/ojpp.2022.124047
[8] Ibid.
[9] Lim, C. Y., Park, J. Y., Kim, D. Y., Yoo, K. D., Kim, H. J., Kim, Y., & Shin, S. J. (2020). Terminal lucidity in the teaching hospital setting. Death Studies, 44(5), 285–291. https://doi.org/10.1080/07481187.2018.1541943
[10]World Health Organization Dementia 15/03/2023 https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/dementia
[11] Zaron Burnett III Terminal Lucidity: The Researchers Attempting to Prove Your Mind Lives On Even After You Die MEL Magazine 26/09/2018
[12] Roger Lewin Is Your Brain Really Necessary? Science 210, 1232-1234 (1980). Digital Object Identifier (DOI) Number: 10.1126/science.7434023
[13] Neuroskeptic “Is Your Brain Really Necessary?», Revisited Discover Magazine 26/07/2015
[14] Quantum potential is the source of the active information, but ultimately its source is a new quality of energy, which is not present in the classical realm. The appearance of another quality of energy should not surprise us. In thermodynamics we have many notions of energy, internal energy, Helmholtz free energy, Gibbs free energy and even heat energy, all of which arise in general chemical processes; in this case, it arises from brain processes. The advantage with this new quality of energy is that it is “borrowed” from the kinetic energy to shape the overall process but in such a way that energy is always conserved.
[15] Fr. Robert Spitzer, S.J Science at the Doorstep to God Ignatius Press September 11, 2023 ISBN/UPC: 9781621646365
[16] M. Ribes Información, ¿un nuevo paradigma? Bioethics Observatory UCV 26 January, 2024 https://www.observatoriobioetica.org/2024/01/informacion-un-nuevo-paradigma/10000126
[17] Hiley, Basil J., and Paavo Pylkkänen, ‘Can Quantum Mechanics Solve the Hard Problem of Consciousness?’, in Shan Gao (ed.), Consciousness and Quantum Mechanics (New York, 2022; online edn, Oxford Academic, 20 Oct. 2022), https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780197501665.003.0016