Lucía Gómez Tatay, a researcher at the Bioethics Observatory of the Catholic University of Valencia, has participated in the work of the European Parliament’s Committee on Legal Affairs (JURI), providing an analysis of the scientific, ethical, and regulatory implications of this emerging technology.

On November 5, Dr. Lucía Gómez Tatay participated in the “Workshop on legal and ethical challenges posed by new emerging technologies,” organized by the European Parliament’s Committee on Legal Affairs (JURI) at its headquarters in Brussels.

Her contribution focused on the study of the ethical and legal implications of synthetic human genomics, a field that involves the design and construction of human genome sequences using DNA synthesis techniques. To this end, she prepared a report for the European Parliament’s Committee on Legal Affairs (JURI), titled “Synthetic human genomics: state of the art and ethical landscape,” which served as the basis for her presentation to that institution.

Synthetic genomics represents a significant shift in the possibilities for genetic research: moving from reading and modifying DNA sequences toward the ability to design and produce genetic material from scratch.

Although scientists have not yet succeeded in synthesizing a complete human genome or producing a complete synthetic human chromosome, recent scientific advances make it possible to assemble large fragments of human DNA and introduce them into mammalian cells. These advances make it necessary to anticipate the ethical, legal, and social consequences of their potential future development.

Human dignity, reproduction, and the protection of future generations

One of the key issues addressed by Gómez Tatay was the distinction between the applications of synthetic human genomics in biomedical research and its potential reproductive uses.

While research may open up new opportunities for understanding how the genome works, studying diseases, and developing future therapies, its potential use for creating human beings raises questions of particular significance. Among these are the possibility of deliberately designing the genetic characteristics of future individuals, the new forms of reproduction that could emerge, and the implications for genetic parentage and reproductive autonomy.

The risks of the instrumentalization of human life, the selection of non-therapeutic characteristics, and the potential creation of individuals conceived to serve specific interests or purposes were also analyzed.

Gómez Tatay’s report emphasizes that human dignity must serve as the fundamental criterion for evaluating these possibilities. No person should be considered a product designed to meet the expectations or needs of others.

Furthermore, it is argued that the protection of the human embryo should not depend on the technique used to generate it or its development capacity, criteria that other authors have proposed and whose acceptance would mean unprotecting human embryos generated using these novel techniques.

Gómez Tatay, on the other hand, argued that their classification as embryos should be based solely on their biological nature.

Genetic privacy and new challenges for biosecurity

Another notable aspect of this report is the transformation that these technologies could bring about in the protection of genetic information.

The ability to reconstruct genetic material from digital information, without the need for cells or tissues from the individual, raises new risks related to privacy, consent, and control over genomic data.

This capability could facilitate the unauthorized replication of individual genomes, their use for reproductive purposes without the affected person’s knowledge, and even the fabrication of false genetic test results.

The study differentiates these risks from the traditional biosafety and biosecurity problems associated with the synthesis of potentially dangerous organisms. Therefore, it proposes to address threats related to genetic information through specific safeguards regarding consent, privacy, data protection and reproductive autonomy, instead of indiscriminately resorting to mechanisms for detecting pathogenic sequences.

The need to adapt the European regulatory framework

The report also assesses the legal framework currently in force within the European Union. It concludes that there is no need to create an entirely new regulatory regime, as existing legal instruments already provide substantial protection. These include the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, the General Data Protection Regulation, regulations concerning genetically modified organisms, and provisions relating to biomedical research and human rights.

However, it identifies an important issue: much of the current legislation is drafted with the modification of pre-existing genetic material in mind, whereas synthetic genomics allows for its production from scratch. This technical difference should not lead to unequal legal protection when the activities and their associated risks are functionally equivalent.

For this reason, Gómez Tatay argues for the need to interpret and, where appropriate, adapt existing regulations from a technologically neutral perspective. She also highlights the opportunity presented by upcoming European legislation on biotechnology, the so-called “Biotech Act”, to harmonize mechanisms for control, user verification, and the oversight of nucleic acid synthesis.

The report pays special attention to the protection of human embryos, heritable genetic interventions, genomic privacy, and animal welfare, areas in which it will be necessary to clarify the application of existing safeguards as technology advances.

Science and innovation in the service of humanity

Lucía Gómez Tatay’s participation in this European Parliament project highlights the importance of incorporating bioethical reflection from the very early stages of the development of new biomedical technologies.

Synthetic human genomics may offer significant opportunities for research and the development of new therapeutic tools. However, progress in this field must be accompanied by a rigorous assessment of its consequences and safeguards that ensure respect for human dignity, fundamental rights, animal welfare, and responsibility toward future generations.

The report’s proposal advocates for anticipatory and proportionate governance: promoting scientific research and its potential benefits, while simultaneously establishing limits and safeguards to steer technological development toward the well-being of individuals and society.

 

 

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!