Why can a single embryo split and give rise to two genetically identical individuals? The origin of identical, or monozygotic, twins remains one of the great questions in developmental biology. New research has identified a persistent epigenetic signature in these twins that could provide clues to the mechanisms involved in their formation. Although a causal relationship has not yet been established, the findings open up new scientific perspectives and raise important philosophical and bioethical questions about human individuation, the beginning of life, and the status of the embryo.
What is the genome?
Since the discovery of the molecular structure of DNA in the 1950s, scientists have known that it contains the genetic information necessary for human development. Part of this information is found in protein-coding genes, which contain the instructions for making proteins, molecules that are essential for the structure and functioning of our body. These regions account for approximately 1-2% of the human genome.
The rest is made up of non-coding regions, including numerous regulatory sequences that help control when, where, and to what extent genes are expressed. This regulation is essential for each cell type (such as skin, liver, neuronal, and muscle cells) to activate the specific genetic programs required to perform its particular functions.
What is the epigenome?
The double helix structure of DNA contains information that is necessary—though not sufficient—to explain how a complex organism develops. What remained unclear, however, was how the same genome could give rise to such radically different cells and tissues during embryonic development. There had to be a control “above” the genes, one that required an explanation at the molecular level. The search for that answer led to the emergence of a new scientific discipline: epigenetics. The contemporary and most widely cited definition of this discipline, still valid today, is “the study of heritable changes in gene function that cannot be explained by changes in DNA sequence.”[1]
In the 1960s, researchers began to study the role of histones, the proteins that package DNA. They observed that these proteins inhibit transcription (the reading of genes), in what became the first specific molecular mechanism proposed to control gene activity without changing the DNA sequence. In the 1970s, it was suggested that DNA methylation—a biochemical mechanism by which the cell adds small chemical groups to specific sites on the DNA—allows gene activity to be regulated without altering the genetic information.
In recent decades, epigenetic research has considerably broadened our understanding of how cells establish and maintain their functional characteristics. It has also enabled us to study how certain environmental factors and developmental signals may influence genetic regulation, without implying that all environmental responses are epigenetic or that all epigenetic marks are passed on to offspring.
The epigenome at the beginning of life
This knowledge allows us to better understand some of the processes that take place at the beginning of human development. In the review article Epigenetic regulation of early human embryo development,[2] published in 2023, researchers affiliated with the Babraham Institute examined advances in the understanding of epigenetic regulation during the early stages of human embryo development.
In the first few days after fertilization, the embryo undergoes profound and coordinated epigenetic changes, which are essential for the embryo to transition from a single cell to an organized multicellular organism. The general function of epigenetics in this process is to act as a control and memory system. After fertilization, the embryo has to “reset” the epigenetic information inherited from the highly specialized sperm and oocyte, in order to restore a flexible state capable of generating all types of cells in the body. This reset enables coordinated activation of the embryo genome and allows cells to begin differentiating into the correct lineages (the cells that will form the fetus, placenta, and other supporting structures).
Epigenetics can be understood, in part, as a system of regulation and cellular memory. Some epigenetic states help to maintain the characteristics acquired during development, while others are modified in response to new signals, allowing cells to adopt different fates.
However, this is not an autonomous program that determines development on its own. Epigenetic regulation works in interaction with the DNA sequence, transcription factors, cellular signals, and the conditions of the embryonic environment.
Together, these processes ensure that early development proceeds in a coordinated manner and help establish the necessary conditions for the formation of the organism.
Identical twins
Identical, or monozygotic, twins form when the offspring of a single fertilized egg, the zygote, divides into two or more embryos during the early stages of development. To this day, the origin and birth of identical twins remains a complete mystery. However, the steady advance of molecular biology suggests that this unique phenomenon also has its origin in the epigenome.
The research has focused on the analysis of epigenetic information in the chromosomes of identical twins and other individuals. Specifically, DNA methylation controls which genes are “turned on” and which are “turned off” in each cell of the body. They identified 834 locations in the DNA where the level of methylation differed between identical twins and non-twins. As Miina Ollikainen of the Institute of Molecular Medicine at the University of Helsinki concludes: “The results point to unusual methylation patterns in genes involved in cell adhesion which might explain why there is spontaneous fission of an early developing embryo into two identical halves.”[5] These findings suggest that monozygotic twinning leaves a persistent epigenetic signature associated with early genome programming.
The philosophical importance of this research
The finding of a shared, lifelong signature in monozygotic twins does not prove the existence of a specific molecular mechanism or predisposition in the early stages of embryonic division. As the author of the study acknowledges, since these are observations, these marks could represent a cause, effect, or by-product of the twinning process. Van Dongen points out that further functional studies in cell or animal models are needed to determine exactly how this signature relates to monozygotic twinning.[6]
Nonetheless, the mere possibility of establishing that the division of the zygote into two or more embryos is not due to pure mechanical or stochastic chance, but rather to early predisposition or epigenetic imprinting, has enormous philosophical and bioethical implications. If a molecular origin for twinning were to be confirmed, it would reshape the ontological concept of individuation. This would suggest that the uniqueness of the individual does not emerge purely through environmental influences or at later stages, but rather has programming markers established in the earliest stages of development — a conceptual horizon that is directly linked to normative debates on the status of the embryo.[7] It should be remembered that the 14-day limit adopted in many countries to allow research on human embryos is based precisely on the loss of the capacity for twinning as a criterion for individuation.
Manuel Ribes
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
[1] Gary Felsenfeld. A Brief History of Epigenetics Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol 2014;6:a018200
[2] Wilkinson AL, Zorzan I, Rugg-Gunn PJ. Epigenetic regulation of early human embryo development. Cell Stem Cell. 2023 Dec 7;30(12):1569-1584. doi: 10.1016/j.stem.2023.09.010.
[3] van Dongen, J., Gordon, S.D., McRae, A.F. et al. Identical twins carry a persistent epigenetic signature of early genome programming. Nat Commun 12, 5618 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25583-7
[4] Jonathan Lambert All identical twins may share a common set of chemical markers on their DNA Science News SEPTEMBER 28, 2021
[5] New leads in research into the origin of identical twins Institute for Molecular Medicine Finland FIMM, HiLIFE, University of Helsinki 28.9.2021
[6] Jenny van Dongen, Nikki Hubers, Dorret I Boomsma. New insights into the (epi)genetics of twinning. Human Reproduction, Volume 39, Issue 1, January 2024, Pages 35–42, https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dead131
[7] M. Ribes The moral value of the human being. Bioethics Observatory 31 January, 2025 https://bioethicsobservatory.org/2025/01/the-moral-value-of-the-human-being/47511/