Human beings have been recognized as having a moral value since the dawn of human history. We have been aware of the practice of funeral rituals since the Neanderthals began burying their dead about 100,000 years ago, a clear sign of the moral consideration of the human person.
A question that humans have also asked themselves since time immemorial is, at what point during the imperceptible events that occur within the mother’s womb does the being that merits the moral consideration of person emerge? This is a topic on which philosophers and thinkers of all ages have spoken with very different answers, more often than not based on a very erroneous scientific knowledge of the origin of life.
In the 5th century BC, Hippocrates of Kos believed that organisms were fully formed and miniaturized within germinal entities, a notion that persisted for centuries. It was not until the 18th century, when Caspar F Wolf wrote his dissertation “Theoria Generationis”, that Aristotle’s idea that the female provided the constitutive material of the embryo, while this material was vitalized by the male, took hold. Nevertheless, it was not until the 1960s, with in vitro cultures of animal embryos, that effective progress was made in understanding early embryonic development.
Biological stages of human development
Human fertilization is the union of a female egg and a male sperm that usually occurs in the fallopian tube. The result of this union is the production of a cell, the zygote or fertilized egg, in which a unique genome is created and embryo development begins. As it moves down the fallopian tube towards the uterus, the zygote undergoes a series of divisions, reaching 16 cells in 3 days, in what is called the morula stage.
During the third and fourth week, a process called gastrulation takes place, by which the body plan is developed: the cells of the embryo begin to organize themselves into different layers, constituting the origin of the formation of different tissues and organs, characteristic of the adult individual. With gastrulation, the embryo loses the flexibility to reorganize and, consequently, the ability to divide into monozygotic twins.
The embryonic stage lasts until 8 weeks after fertilization, during which the body plan, ossification and sex differentiation are completed. From then on, the embryo is called a fetus.
In the ninth week, the fetal period begins, which lasts until birth. During fetal life, no new organs or tissues are formed; rather, the existing ones mature. At around weeks 24-28, the fetus is considered to acquire the human-specific electroencephalogram (EEG).
Birth takes place between weeks 37 and 42. The first breath occurs about 10 seconds after delivery, causing a series of changes in the lungs and circulatory system.
When is moral consideration acquired?
Contemporary society is increasingly questioning when it should confer moral status on an embryo, requiring an answer in order to properly address the ethical, legal and social issues arising from man’s interference in many aspects and stages of life.
This answer must be framed within the consideration that science provides data on the physical development of the human being, but does not provide information on his or her personhood and uniqueness. To form an opinion, we need to turn to a synthesis between data and scientific hypotheses, philosophical thought and the humanities.
The majority view among scientists is that personhood begins at fertilization. Geneticists explain that this is where life begins, a unique genome is created, and the conditions are in place to generate a new person.
The “neurological” argument submits that personhood begins when the fetus acquires a human-specific EEG pattern. Several arguments are put forward for this: if the EEG pattern determines the end of life, it should also define the beginning of human life; Morowitz and Trefil argue that, just as our species acquired humanness when the enlarged cortex developed, the individual fetus acquires humanness when its cortex begins to function.[3]
The moment of childbirth is the milestone that some consider the time of one’s identity. According to Hebrew tradition, this is when the nephesh, the soul, enters the body, and therefore the fetus only acquires full human rights and status once the baby’s head has passed through the birth canal.
The definition of person to the rescue
Notwithstanding, the delimitation of the time at which moral consideration is acquired requires a philosophical analysis that must necessarily start from the definition of person, for as Frederick White of Northwestern State University states, “personhood is an essential characteristic of the human species and is not a conditional state dependent upon circumstance, perception, cognition, or societal dictum”. [4] Furthermore, according to Farah and Heberlein, “Personhood is a foundational concept in ethics, including both pure philosophical ethics and the applied field of bioethics”. [5]
The definition of person is a controversial topic in philosophy, and very different definitions have been proposed for this term. Nevertheless, the one formulated by Boethius, expressed centuries ago as “an individual substance with a rational nature”, remains valid and functional over time. In relation to the definition, Paolo Sommaggio, professor at the University of Trento, affirms that “today [it] is regarded as the basis for any convincing discourse on the person”,[6] while Peter L. Simpson, professor at the City University of New York, believes that “a philosophy of person grounded on that definition is going to be
more accurate and more compelling than others”.[7]
Those who accept the first hypothesis consider that being a person implies something more than being human, and that certain functions such as consciousness, reasoning, self-determination, communication and self-awareness are required to acquire the category of person. In general terms, they are based on John Locke’s definition of a person, which Peter Singer sets out as follows: “A thinking intelligent being that has reason and reflection and can consider itself as itself, the same thinking thing, in different times and places”. [8] According to this line of thought, the person is defined on the basis of capacity, and determining when the development of certain organs is adequate to guarantee the status of a person is arbitrary. As Miklavcic and Flaman stress, “the appearance and development of organs cannot be a criterion for personhood”. [9] Elaborating on Locke’s thesis, a baby would not be a person, since a baby lacks the capacity to reason and to consider himself as himself. Stephen D. Schwarz believes that this philosophy confuses the functions of human beings with their own nature.[10]
Based on Boethius’ definition (person is “an individual substance with a rational nature”), it follows that one is a person based on being a certain kind of thing, not on having certain capacities at the present time or even at some future or past time. The second hypothesis is therefore in accordance with this definition. At the time of fertilization, both the sperm and the oocyte lose their identity and their components form a new organism, a human embryo that has all the necessary information within and is actively disposed to develop into a mature human body. This means that, at any of the stages of its development (embryo, fetus, baby) until the mature human being, the same type of entity is maintained, with the only difference being in the degree of maturation. The human being does not become a human person at some point in the development of the embryo, it does not change its entity at any time; rather, a human person is already present at the time of fertilization. The only phenomenon found in the entire cycle of formation of a human being beginning at fertilization is a maturation process directed from the outset by the genetic and epigenetic content of the zygote. For this reason, Lee and George explain that having moral status “belongs to a human being at all times that he or she exists, not just during certain stages of his or her existence”.
Objections to personhood of the zygote
Agata Sagan and Peter Singer from Princeton University have objected to the attribution of personhood to the zygote, stating that stem cells would also warrant the same treatment: “it would seem that if the human embryo has moral standing and is entitled to protection in virtue of what it can become, then the same must be true of human embryonic stem cells”. [12] Their reasoning resides in the fact that a stem cell is capable of generating a human embryo by fusing it with an enucleated egg, which they consider simply a suitable environment. This is not the reality, however, since the enucleated egg is not only a suitable environment, but actively contributes to reprogramming the fused nucleus by changing the epigenetic state of what was initially a stem cell. The production of a new organism, an embryo, requires the help of a stem cell and necessarily the cytoplasm of an egg, not any “suitable environment”.[13]
The 14-day criterion
These arguments underestimate the level of interaction and differentiation between the cells of the zygote at this stage. Robert P. George and Alfonso Gómez-Lobo’s explanation is enlightening: “The clearest evidence that the embryo in the first two weeks is not a mere mass of cells but is a unitary organism is this: if the individual cells within the embryo before twinning were each independent of the others, there would be no reason why each would not regularly develop on its own. Instead, these allegedly independent, noncommunicating cells regularly function together to develop into a single, more mature member of the human species. This fact shows that interaction is taking place between the cells from the very beginning (even within the zona pellucida, before implantation), restraining them from individually developing as whole organisms and directing each of them to function as a relevant part of a single, whole organism continuous with the zygote. Thus, prior to an extrinsic division of the cells of the embryo, these cells together do constitute a single organism. So, the fact of twinning does not show that the embryo is a mere incidental mass of cells. Rather, the evidence clearly indicates that the human embryo, from the zygote stage forward, is a unitary, human organism”.[15]
A must-ask question
In a recent 2021 paper, Steven A. Jacobs of the University of Chicago published the results of a study that was approved by the university’s Institutional Review Board for Social and Behavioral Sciences.[16] It contains the following statements:
- “Peer-reviewed journals in the biological and life sciences literature have published articles that represent the biological view that a human’s life begins at fertilization (“the fertilization view”)”.
- “Biologists from 1,058 academic institutions around the world assessed survey items on when a human’s life begins and, overall, 96% (5337 out of 5577) affirmed the fertilization view”.
- “Based on the totality of the biological and life sciences literature’s recognition of the fertilization view, principles of the modern genetics-based method of biologically classifying organisms, and the data reported in the present study, the fertilization view stands alone as the leading biological view on when a human’s life begins”.
All this compels us to ask ourselves the question: Why does society ignore this evidence?
Manuel Ribes
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
[1] Quoted by Scott Gilbert in his 2009 American Reproductive Health Association Burnhill Award lecture “When Does Personhood Begin?”
[2] John B Appleby & Annelien L. Bredenoord Should the 14‐day rule for embryo research become the 28‐day rule? EMBO Mol Med (2018) 10: e9437 https://doi.org/10.15252/emmm.201809437
[3] Scott F. Gilbert Pseudo-Embryology And Personhood: How Embryological Pseudoscience Helps Structure The American Abortion Debate Natural Sciences 2022 DOI: 10.1002/ntls.2022004
[4] White FJ. Personhood: An essential characteristic of the human species. Linacre Q. 2013 Feb;80(1):74-97. doi: 10.1179/0024363912Z.00000000010. PMID: 24845541; PMCID: PMC6081772.
[5] Farah MJ, Heberlein AS. Personhood and neuroscience: naturalizing or nihilating? Am J Bioeth. 2007 Jan;7(1):37-48. doi: 10.1080/15265160601064199. PMID: 17366164.
[6] Sommaggio, Paolo Boethius’ definition of persona: a fundamental principle of modern legal thought IVR-Symposium Lund 2003 Corpus ID: 169967469
[7] Peter Simpson The Definition of Person: Boethius Revisited – The New Scholasticism Volume 62, Issue 2, Pages 210-220 Spring 1988
[8] Justin Kalan Peter Singer Forgets Boethius Word on Fire August 2024
[9] Miklavcic JJ, Flaman P. Personhood status of the human zygote, embryo, fetus. Linacre Q. 2017 May; 84(2):130-144. doi: 10.1080/00243639.2017.1299896
[10] Khanh Trinh Is the Early Human Embryo a Person? A Metaphysical Defense of Personhood ESS Open Archive April 24, 2024
[11] Lee, Patrick, and Robert P. George. The wrong of abortion. In Contemporary debates in applied ethics, ed. A.I. Cohen and C.H. Wellman, 13–26. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 2005
[12] Robert P. George & Patrick Lee Embryonic human persons EMBO reports Vol 10 | no 4 | 2009
[13] Ibid.
[14] RAMSAY M. Twinning and Fusion as Arguments against the Moral Standing of the Early Human Embryo Utilitas 2011;23(2):183-205. doi:10.1017/S0953820811000057
[15] Ibid.
[16] Jacobs SA. The Scientific Consensus on When a Human’s Life Begins Issues Law Med. 2021 Fall;36(2):221-233. PMID: 36629778.