A historical perspective
Consciousness is the ethereal fabric that gives rise to our subjective experiences, our perception of the world, and our sense of self. For many millennia, this concept has been associated with religious or philosophical thought that considers the existence of a soul, connected in some mysterious way to the body. Deeply intertwined with the concept of consciousness, the notion of free will — the capacity to make choices independent of any outside influence — has been recognized.
Attempts to develop a systematic approach to the study of consciousness began with René Descartes in the 17th century. However, his dualistic view, which stated that consciousness is a state of mind, with the brain having a role restricted to non-conscious processes, placed consciousness outside the domain of science. The Scientific Enlightenment embraced materialism and, following its principles, inquiry into the world was restricted to physical substances, abandoning the study of subjective cognitive processes. This school of thought persists to this day, given that we are slaves to our neurons, lacking true free will.
The early 20th century saw the advent of quantum theory, which describes the behavior of matter and energy at their most elementary levels. According to this theory, nature acts in a non-deterministic way, thus bringing a fresh perspective to the study of consciousness. In fact, the scientists who embarked on this innovative approach had already sensed this possibility. Niels Bohr suggested that quantum theory could be relevant to understanding biological systems and even the mind[1], while Max Planck stated: “I regard consciousness as fundamental. I regard matter as derivative from consciousness”[2].
The quantum explanation of consciousness grows and gains supporters
The way in which interactions are explained in quantum theory helps us to comprehend the processes of change. Effectively, in contrast to classical physics, which describes composite systems by combining the parts additively, quantum theory employs a multiplicative approach, which allows for new possibilities of the whole that cannot be expected from the properties of the parts alone. Consequently, quantum theory provides the scientific foundation for explaining the emergence of new entities. A whole is completely different and new, as we can see, for example, in the formation of water molecules, in which the properties of water differ greatly from those of hydrogen and oxygen gases. Quantum theory therefore allows us to explain the evolutionary process from inanimate matter to living beings.
Quantum mechanics reveals a world of probabilities and interconnections that presents two fundamental characteristics: the superposition principle, by which quantum entities can exist in multiple states simultaneously until they are measured; and entanglement, which a certain Einstein, baffled by its evidence, called “spooky action at a distance”[3], whereby particles can entangle their fates, regardless of the distance separating them.
Many scientists now think that these phenomena are not mere peculiarities of the microscopic world, but are essential to the functioning of the brain and the emergence of consciousness. They could explain phenomena such as free will, creativity and the binding problem, i.e., how disparate sensory inputs merge into a unified conscious experience.
Notably, the existence of entanglement, which even affects particles that are light-years apart, suggests that our thoughts extend beyond the boundaries of the brain, and that consciousness is intimately connected to the universe around us, with which the neurons in the brain communicate instantaneously over vast distances.
In the last few years, a growing body of empirical evidence has emerged, even in the field of biology, which supports these concepts. For example, research has shown that certain quantum effects, such as quantum coherent energy transfer and entanglement, play a role in photosynthesis[4], the process that forms the very basis of life. Similarly, studies suggest that European robins use the quantum entanglement of their cryptochrome proteins to sense the Earth’s magnetic field, enabling them to navigate accurately over distances of 2,500 kilometers[5].
Moreover, very recently, it seems that the particular role of quantum entanglement in the human brain has been verified. This would allow us to explain the consciousness in the brain through instant information transfer and synchronization of the activities of millions of neurons. In a paper published in 2024 in Physical Review E[6], physicists Zefei Liu and Yong-Cong Chen of Shanghai University and biomedical engineer Ping Ao of Sichuan University explain how entangled photons emitted by carbon-hydrogen bonds in certain nerve cell cavities could synchronize brain activity.
David Bohm’s proposal provides a valid description of consciousness
Bohm’s explanation is based on quantum mechanics and is consistent with it. It starts from Louis de Broglie’s interpretation of “pilot wave”, in which he introduces new ideas that suggest a radically different view of nature, while not making any empirical difference.
Matter (and also brain matter) is composed of particles that we know are made up of quantum fields, which interact in space-time. Bohm postulates that an electron is always both a particle and a field at the same time. The field gives rise to a quantum potential that influences the movement of particles. Mathematics suggests that the form of the quantum field is literally “in-forming” the energy of the particle. Paavo Pylkkänen[9] likens it to the way a radar wave guides a ship on autopilot: “The radar wave does not push or pull the ship, but rather the form of the radar wave (which reflects the form of the environment) informs the greater energy of the ship. Analogously, Bohm thought that the quantum field carries information about the form of the environment […] and this information directs the particle to move in a particular way”.
Just as there is a quantum field that informs the motion of the particle, there is a super-quantum field that informs the motion of the first-order quantum field, and so on. Together it constitutes a universally distributed non-local quantum holographic information network[10] that connects our consciousness to the quantum-holographic cosmos.
It is a non-local quantum information unfolding that self-organizes matter, life, mind, and consciousness. The information in our mental states is a part of the information contained in this hierarchy of quantum information fields. This information in our mental states influences neural processes by reaching the quantum particles and fields in an appropriate part of the brain.
Thus, Bohm proposes a solution to the problem of mental causation. This active information at the quantum level provides the missing link between the mental and physical aspects of reality. Human thought and choice affect the quantum fields intrinsic to the elementary particles in the brain (and, through the brain, to the rest of the body). Consciousness emerges as an infinite sequence of quantum potentials at successive levels, each controlling the one below.
This mechanism by which individual consciousness can be detached from an underlying “field” of consciousness constitutes an explanation of the mind-brain relationship that determines free conscious rational choice and satisfies experimental observations that point to a mind or soul outside the realm of classical physics.
In line with this theory, Stanford neuroscientist Karl Pribram has developed a model of human cognition[11] that describes the brain as a holographic storage network. He noticed the similarities
An analogy to this proposal is the distribution of radio waves in a region of space, in which all channels can be accessed at any point, similar to how the entirety of the information in a hologram is contained within a part.
A revolutionary idea or a return to the past?
The basic mathematical property of holographic systems, in which the information of the whole system is distributed in each part of the system, is inherent to the underlying field of consciousness that pervades the universe and with which we are connected.
Professor Francisco Di Biase finds this holoinformational nature of the universe reflected in the beautiful Buddhist metaphor of Indra’s net[12], whose origin goes back a thousand years before the start of our era: In the heavenly abode of the great god Indra, there is a wonderful net which stretches out indefinitely in all directions. There is a single glittering jewel at the
net’s every node, infinite in number. If we select one of these jewels and look closely at it, we will discover that in its polished surface there are reflected all the other jewels in the net, infinite in number. Each of the jewels reflected in this one jewel is also reflecting all the other jewels, so that the process of reflection is infinite.
This metaphor shows a Cosmos with an infinite network of holograms, in which each part of this holographic system contains information about all the others, each defining and maintaining all others.
Manuel Ribes
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
[1] Paavo Pylkkänen Quantum Theories of Consciousness R. Gennaro ed.The Routledge Handbook of Consciousness 2018
[2] Ediho Lokanga A Special Relationship between Matter, Energy, Information, and Consciousness International Journal of Recent advances in Physics 2020 https://doi.org/10.14810/ijrap.2020.9301
[3] Manuel Ribes El Nobel de Física para “la acción espeluznante a distancia” –UCV Bioethics Observatory, 25 October 2022
[4] Neill Lambert et al. Quantum biology Nature Physics 2012 DOI: 10.1038/NPHYS2474
[5] Marta Majewska et al. European Robin Cryptochrome-4a Associates with Lipid Bilayers in an Ordered Manner, Fulfilling a Molecular-Level Condition for Magnetoreception ACS Chemical Biology 2025 https://doi.org/10.1021/acschembio.4c00576
[6] Zefei Liu et al. Entangled biphoton generation in myelin sheath arXiv:2401.11682v2 [physics.bio-ph] 21 Aug 2024
[7] Hiley, Basil J., and Paavo Pylkkänen, ‘Can Quantum Mechanics Solve the Hard Problem of Consciousness?’, in Shan Gao (ed.), Consciousness and Quantum Mechanics (New York, 2022; online edn, Oxford Academic, 20 Oct. 2022), DOI:10.1093/oso/9780197501665.003.0016
[8] Manuel Ribes ¿Qué nos dice la ciencia sobre el alma? UCV Bioethics Observatory, 26 June 2024
[9] Paavo Pylkkänen Quantum Theories of Consciousness R. Gennaro ed. The Routledge Handbook of Consciousness 2018
[10] In 1948, Dennis Gabor developed a technique for recording the amplitude and phase of the light wave to obtain a three-dimensional image of an object, a technique known as holography. The hologram is Bohm’s favorite metaphor for conveying the structure of reality. One of the main characteristics of a hologram is that every part of the stored information is distributed over the entire hologram.
[11] David Peat David Bohm, Implicate Order and Holomovement Science and Nonduality Dec 13 2024
[12] Di Biase F., Quantum Entanglement of Consciousness and Space-Time A Unied Field of Consciousness NeuroQuantology | March 2019| Volume 17 | Issue 03 | Page 80-85| doi: 10.14704/nq.2019.17.03.1993