The concept of “nothing” has been the subject of philosophical reflection for centuries, but in recent decades, theoretical physics has burst into this debate with new and provocative hypotheses. Could the universe have originated from a quantum “nothing”? What does this “nothing” mean from a physical point of view, and to what extent can it replace—or redefine—the traditional philosophical notion? This article rigorously explores the theories that postulate the spontaneous origin of the cosmos from quantum vacuum fluctuations, reviewing the main scientific proposals, their ontological implications, and the criticisms they raise, taking us from quantum mechanics to the limits of contemporary philosophical thought.
The Vacuum: from absolute absence to quantum effervescence
In the field of physics, the concept of “vacuum” classically refers to a state of space where there are no particles or energy. However, this notion of a vacuum as a total absence of matter and energy directly contradicts the uncertainty principle. According to this fundamental principle, formulated by Werner Heisenberg, if we were to consider an absolutely empty region of space, this would imply that the force fields within it would have a precise value of zero, a condition that violates quantum constraints. Far from being an inert space, the vacuum is therefore permeated by so-called quantum fluctuations: the spontaneous and fleeting creation and annihilation of pairs of virtual particles.
The beginning of the universe
Our knowledge of cosmic expansion allows us to piece together the evolution of the universe up to a fraction of a second after the Big Bang with remarkable reliability. Immediately after this event, there would have been a very brief but extraordinary episode of exponential expansion known as “cosmic inflation”.
The information we have access to within the observable universe, i.e., data that we can measure or infer, is limited to the last ~10⁻³³ seconds of the inflationary phase and all that followed. The total duration of the inflation remains unknown: it may have lasted slightly longer than that minimum observable or may extend indefinitely in some regions of space, as postulated by the eternal inflation hypothesis. This duration is not only unknown, but could be fundamentally unknowable from an empirical point of view.
With respect to the mechanism that gave rise to the inflation, here we venture into the realm of theoretical speculation. Although there are several hypotheses and intense research is being conducted, we do not have a definitive explanation. For now, we have neither direct observations nor conceivable experiments that can conclusively resolve this primordial question about the beginning of our universe.
An original hypothesis: the universe emerges from a vacuum fluctuation
In 1973, Edward Tryon, at that time at Columbia University, put forward a seminal idea regarding the application of quantum mechanics to the origin of the universe. Extrapolating the concept of quantum fluctuations to the universe as a whole, he suggested that if the only thing that existed was a quantum vacuum, then a spontaneous bubble-like energy fluctuation could have given rise to the universe. According to Tryon, the whole universe could be the result of a quantum vacuum fluctuation, arising from what he called “quantum nothingness”.[1]
Among the most influential theories inspired by this approach are Alexander Vilenkin’s model of quantum tunneling from nothing, according to which the universe emerges from a state with no space or time through a quantum process; Hartle and Hawking’s no-boundary proposal, which eliminates the notion of a definite initial instant; and the thesis popularized by Lawrence Krauss, who argues that the universe can arise “from nothing” as long as that quantum “nothing” has physical structure and is governed by laws.
Trying to redefine “nothing”
The most controversial point in considering the spontaneous origin of the universe lies in explaining how the “quantum vacuum”, despite its well-defined physical properties, can be conceived as a form of “nothing”. Philosophically, “nothing” is commonly understood as the absolute absence of all that exists, the radical denial of reality and existence.
In this context, Lawrence Krauss stands as one of the most emphatic defenders of a new concept: “true nothingness”. With this idea, Krauss seeks not only to replace, but even invalidate, the traditional philosophical notion of “nothingness”. In early 2012, he published his book under the provocative title A Universe from Nothing. Krauss defended his fundamental ideas in an interview with Ross Andersen for The Atlantic, published on 23 April 2012 under the title Has physics made philosophy and religion obsolete?[2] In it, he argues that the quantum vacuum is a physically unstable state that tends to generate “something”, such as particles and even space-time itself. From his perspective, this constitutes an origin “from nothing”, since it does not start from pre-existing matter or space in the classical sense.
Krauss bases part of his argument on ideas from quantum gravity, a still-speculative theoretical field that requires experimental confirmation. He himself acknowledges the hypothetical nature of his approach: “Given what we know about quantum gravity, or what we presume about quantum gravity, we know you can create space from where there was no space. And so you’ve got a situation where there were no particles in space, but also there was no space. That’s a lot closer to ‘nothing’”.
When the interviewer asks him how a state that is subject to the laws of quantum field theory can be considered “nothing”, Krauss replies that, although it has some content, it is the “nothing” that is relevant from the physical point of view, the “nothing of reality”. Krauss says that: “When I talk about empty space, I am talking about a quantum vacuum, but when I’m talking about no
In short, Krauss posits that physics is capable of redefining the concept of “nothing” as a fundamental physical state, dispensing with traditional metaphysical categories.
Krauss’s proposals have sparked strong criticism both from philosophy and from theoretical physics itself. David Albert, philosopher and doctor of theoretical physics, professor at Columbia University, harshly refuted these theories in an article for The New York Times: “The particular, eternally persisting, elementary physical stuff of the world, according to the standard presentations of relativistic quantum field theories, consists (unsurprisingly) of relativistic quantum fields. (…) [These theories] have nothing whatsoever to say on the subject of where those fields came from, or of why the world should have consisted of the particular kinds of fields it does, or of why it should have consisted of fields at all, or of why there should have been a world in the first place”.[3]
In a similar vein, Marcelo Gleiser, a theoretical physicist and renowned scientific popularizer, argues that a complete description of the origin of the universe must necessarily include the origin of the laws of nature. In his words: “Every scientific theory is built upon a set of concepts. For example, we use what we call the laws of nature, which are statements of regularities that we find in the behavior of physical systems, such as the conservation of momentum and energy. It’s hard to imagine how to construct a theory of the origin of everything that doesn’t make use of such law. Yet, a theory describing the origin of the universe should, as a matter of principle, also explain the origin of the laws of nature”.[4]
What is it that breathes fire into the equations?
Consequently, although research on the fundamental laws operating in the quantum vacuum will allow us to deepen our understanding of the primordial moments after the Big Bang, the question that Stephen Hawking poetically expressed will remain scientifically unanswered: “What is it that breathes fire into the equations and makes a universe for them to describe?”[5] Cosmologist Martin Rees of Trinity College echoes this limitation by pointing out that physics alone “can never explain what ‘breathes fire’ into the equations and actualised them into a real cosmos”. Thus he concludes that the fundamental question of “why is there something rather than nothing?” remains, ultimately, within the purview of philosophical inquiry.[6]
Manuel Ribes
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
[1] Tryon, E. P. (1973). Is the Universe a Vacuum Fluctuation? Nature, 246(5433), 396–397. https://doi.org/10.1038/246396a0
[2] Ross Andersen Has Physics Made Philosophy and Religion Obsolete? The Atlantic April 23, 2012
[3] David Albert On the Origin of Everything The New York Times March 23, 2012
[4] Marcelo Gleiser Could All Really Come From Nothing? NPR Cosmos & Culture OCTOBER 15, 2015
[5] Stephen Hawking A Brief History of Time Bantam Books 1998 ISBN-10: 0553109537
[6] Martin Rees Just Six Numbers: The Deep Forces that Shape the Universe Basic Books 2000 ISBN 0-465-03672-4