This article discusses the eternal space race, highlighting the fundamental dilemma between human and robotic exploration. From a bioethical perspective, humans are extremely vulnerable in the cosmic environment because our biology, shaped by the Earth, is not made for space; radiation damages DNA and the absence of gravity atrophies the body.
Although it was argued throughout the history of the Apollo program that unmanned probes were more logical and efficient for obtaining scientific data, political interests, initially driven by the Cold War, dictated human endeavor.
This tension has now been reignited by the geopolitical competition between the United States (Artemis program) and China, coupled with the emergence of the private sector’s commercial interests, forcing us to ethically re-evaluate the justification for exposing human life to extreme risks in space in exchange for objectives such as global supremacy or the establishment of commercial regulations.
The space dilemma: humans or robots?
Humans are not made for space. Our biology, shaped by millions of years of evolution on Earth, is extremely vulnerable outside its atmosphere. Cosmic radiation damages DNA, temperatures fluctuate between lethal extremes (the –270°C of the interstellar vacuum or the 5,000°C on the surface of the Sun) and the absence of gravity atrophies our body. This fundamental vulnerability prompted many scientists to defend robotic exploration as the most logical and efficient option from the very beginning.
In the 1960s, figures such as astrophysicist Thomas Gold and nuclear physicist and Science magazine editor Philip Abelson strongly opposed the manned missions of the Apollo program, arguing that unmanned probes provided better scientific data at a vastly lower cost. However, political interests have time and again dictated human presence in outer space.
The Cold War drives the race to the Moon
President Kennedy’s reaction was immediate. The following week in a note to his vice president, he asked bluntly: “Do we have a chance of defeating the Soviets […]? Is there any other space program which promises dramatic results in which we could win?”.[1] Barely a month later, he petitioned Congress for funding for a goal that would change history: “I believe that this nation should commit itself to achieving the goal, before this decade is out, of landing a man on the Moon and returning him safely to the Earth. No single space project in this period will be more impressive to mankind, or more important for the long-range exploration of space”.[2]
Congress approved the plan, even though polls showed that most Americans opposed the colossal $40 billion spending it would entail. The race to the Moon had begun.
The Apollo program: model of management and technological development
Kennedy’s speeches not only changed public opinion, but instilled a missionary spirit that mobilized more than 400,000 people—scientists, engineers, technicians and astronauts—who put their knowledge and passion at the service of a dream. When Kennedy first visited the NASA facility, he met a janitor who was carrying a broom down the hallway. The president casually asked him what he did for NASA, to which he replied: “I’m helping put a man on the Moon”.[3] Although its veracity is not proven, this anecdote perfectly captures the unity of purpose that permeated the project.
The Apollo program became a model of management and technological development. Kennedy (“…we chose to go to the Moon in this decade…”) left no room for ambiguity. The establishment of a clear, inspiring goal with a fixed deadline was decisive. As astronaut Story Musgrave summed up, Apollo had all the elements of a successful project: a clear focus, clear requirements, a clear goal, and a clear timetable.[4] Along the way, it inspired breakthroughs in computing, materials, and navigation systems that turned science fiction into reality.
After the Moon: a hiatus in human exploration
In parallel, robotic exploration achieved extraordinary successes: legendary probes such as Pioneer, Voyager, Viking, Cassini-Huygens and New Horizons expanded our knowledge of the solar system in extraordinary ways. However, this strategy came at a cost. The lack of human achievements generated a disconnect with the public and the frustration of scientists such as Carolyn Porco, leader of the Imaging Science Team on the Cassini mission, who in 2007 lamented that: “[We] retreated to low Earth orbit, where we’ve spent the last 25 years going round in circles… humans haven’t set foot on the Moon in 35 years”.[5]
China’s awakening and man’s return to the Moon
When Donald Trump entered the White House in 2017, he found a China determined to dispute global leadership, including in space. True to his motto Make America Great Again (which he borrowed from Ronald Reagan), he wanted to make a statement by recovering American greatness in space accomplishments. He offered NASA unlimited funding to carry out a manned mission to Mars before the end of his first term.[6] The answer was clear: he was asking for the impossible and had to settle for a more realistic time frame. In December of that year, the Artemis program was announced, with the aim of returning astronauts to the Moon as a precursor to Mars missions.[7] The plan is structured in three phases: a first unmanned flight, Artemis I (successfully performed in 2022), a second manned flight around the Moon, Artemis II, and finally a human moon landing, Artemis III.
However, the delays in the US program are in contrast with the steady progress of China, which has pledged to send astronauts to the Moon by 2030. As astrophysicist Jacco van Loon has pointed out, “there now appears to be a realistic possibility that China could beat the US in a race that America, arguably, has defined”.[8]
Returning to the White House in 2025, Trump raised the stakes, convinced that “you can’t be number one on Earth if you are number two in space”.[9]. To expedite the return to the Moon, he has drastically cut NASA’s scientific funding, terminating 41 projects. Acting Administrator Sean Duffy made it clear: “I’m committed to getting us back to the Moon before President Trump leaves office. […] We will win the second space race”.[10]
More firepower! The commercial interest of the new private sector
Today, NASA acts largely as a customer buying services from these companies, giving them increasing strategic importance. Moreover, they are aware of the importance of being pioneers. As Mike Gold, a former NASA associate administrator and now the head of a private space company, put it, the stakes are high: “The first country to return to and develop the Moon will ultimately write the rules of the road”.[11]
Artemis II: man’s return to the Moon, live
The wait is almost over. Very soon, in February 2026, the entire world will participate live in a new space endeavor. Four astronauts, a woman and three men, will embark on a 10-day mission in which they will circumnavigate the Moon and observe its far side.
Mission commander Reid Wiseman has said that he and his crew would “see things that no human has ever seen”.[12] In reality, however, it will be all humanity that shares this experience, as NASA will make its motto This time, we’re taking the world with us a reality, broadcasting high definition images of both the interior of the Orion spacecraft and the exterior views captured at every moment.
For now, the United States maintains leadership, and the spectacle of Artemis II will showcase this. However, the next big milestone, setting foot on the Moon again, depends as much on the success of this mission as on the development of the Human Landing System (HLS), which continues to lag behind schedule. Meanwhile, the Chinese program is making steady progress. Geopolitical tension and commercial ambition are, paradoxically, the greatest guarantee that the race for the cosmos will continue.
Manuel Ribes
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References
[1] Memo from President John F. Kennedy to Vice President Lyndon Johnson, April 20, 1961 U.S Capitol Visitor Center https://www.visitthecapitol.gov/artifact/memo-president-john-f-kennedy-vice-president-lyndon-johnson-april-20-1961?
[2] President Kennedy’s Special Message to the Congress on Urgent National Needs, May 25, 1961 John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum
[3] Joe Byerly The Janitor Who Helped Put a Man on the Moon From the Green Notebook, November 4, 2017 https://fromthegreennotebook.com/2017/11/04/the-janitor-whohelp-put-a-man-on-the-moon/
[4] Lane Wallace At What Price the Moon? The Atlantic May 25, 2011
[5] Carolyn Porco NASA GOES DEEP Edge [2.27.07]
[6] Olivia Nuzzi How Trump Offered NASA Unlimited Funding to Go to Mars in His First Term Intelligencer JAN. 22, 2019
[7] Manuel Ribes A new space race Bioethics Observatory November 18, 2022
[8] Jacco van Loon The US is now at risk of losing to China in the race to send people back to the Moon’s surface The Conversation October 25, 2024 https://doi.org/10.64628/AB.s5kgdmg5u
[9] Jason Hoffman and Nicky Robertson Trump touts America’s spirit after successful launch of NASA/SpaceX rocket CNN May 30, 2020
[10] Preston Mizell NASA says America will win ‘the second space race’ against China FoxNews September 04, 2025
[11] Josh Dinner US in real danger of losing the moon race to China, experts tell Senate Space September 4, 2025
[12] Pallab Ghosh Meet the history-making astronauts headed for the Moon BBC NEWS 24 September 2025