The United States Olympic and Paralympic Committee (USOPC) has amended its rules to align with the executive order signed by President Donald Trump in February, which bans transgender women from participating in women’s sports competitions.

The new “Athlete Safety” regulations state that trans athletes will only be allowed to compete in the male category, which also affects non-binary people and intersex people. Some states such as California and Minnesota are resisting the implementation of these guidelines.

Last February, US President Donald Trump signed an executive order banning transgender women from participating in women’s competitions. Now, the United States Olympic and Paralympic Committees (USOPC) have changed their rules to adjust to federal regulations.

Prior to the release of the new “Athlete Safety” regulations, the USOPC had not taken a clear stance on the participation of transgender women in women’s competitions. Instead, it had delegated decisions regarding the eligibility of transgender athletes to the national governing bodies of each sport.

National governing bodies of sports federations in the United States must follow the standard of the United States Olympic and Paralympic Committee.

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) allows each sports federation to decide whether trans athletes can compete in events at the international level. However, since its new president, Kirsty Coventry, was elected a month ago, it is not known if there will be any change in this regard.

During her campaign for IOC president, she said she would protect women in sport, which could mean banning trans women from competing in the women’s category.

As we previously reported, in 2023 the World Athletics Federation banned trans women from participating in women’s competitions, and in 2024 World Aquatics prevented trans athletes from competing in the women’s category.

Bioethical assessment

Biological sex, which is chromosomally determined from conception, determines the development of masculine or feminine characteristics that affect all dimensions of the person.

These are the anatomical, endocrine, metabolic, neurological, immunological and psychological dimensions, which show important differences oriented to the complementarity of both sexes.

In sports competitions, these differences lead to different behaviors, specifically in terms of physical performance.

Trying to ignore these differences that persist even after a gender transition creates a comparative disadvantage against those women who must compete with men who have transitioned to the female gender, since they retain characteristics that give them advantages in sports competition.

Ignoring this phenomenon is a failure to recognize the evidence of biological differences linked to sex and their consequences, and it should not be considered discrimination. Just as it is not to establish sport categories by age, which are intended to provide greater equality of opportunity for athletes in their sporting performance.

Ideologically inspired obstinacy that ignores evidence, as occurs with gender ideology, leads to the creation of absurd situations, falsely justified by appeals to freedom or equality.

Freedom is not possible if we ignore the truth that the profound differences linked to biological sex that define us as human beings do not imply any discrimination. Rather, they provide the diversity that enriches us by complementing each other and allows us to survive as a species.

Julio Tudela and Ester Bosch

Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences

Catholic University of Valencia

 

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!