Argentina’s Supreme Court of Justice has rejected the application of a woman who requested the use of her late husband’s gametes to conceive embryos through assisted reproduction. She had hoped to undergo an intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) procedure using genetic material from her deceased spouse, who died on 17 September 2020.
The woman claims the couple had wanted to start a family. Consequently, in 2016, both signed an informed consent on assisted fertilization to begin treatment. A few years prior to this, in February 2013, her husband had granted her broad general power of attorney for administration and use of the semen samples of the appearing party, which contemplated “using them as many times as deemed necessary”.
However, the Court upheld the ruling of Chamber A of the National Chamber of Appeals in Civil Matters of 7 September 2023, which had rejected the motion filed by the woman.
It considered that the extraordinary appeal filed against the Chamber’s ruling had been wrongfully granted because “it does not meet the requirement of independent substantiation”. As such, the ruling does not enter into the substantive issue and is based on procedural issues.
Legal framework in Argentina
In Argentina, the Law on Medically Assisted Reproduction (Law 26.862) does not explicitly address the use of a decedent’s gametes, leaving a legal void that must be interpreted by the courts.
In other countries such as the United Kingdom (UK) and the United States (US), there are legal precedents and clearer regulatory frameworks on the use of posthumous gametes. In the UK, for example, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) states that explicit consent from the donor is required for use of their gametes after their death.
At the opposite end of the spectrum are countries whose rules are more lenient, such as the Netherlands, Portugal and Belgium, although one of the conditions is that there must be written consent and it must be done within a period not exceeding three years following death of the person.
It is also important to note that some of these countries in which it is regulated make some distinctions. For example, in some cases it may only be done if the donor is the partner and not the son or daughter.
The law in Spain
In Spain, posthumous fatherhood has been legal since the enactment of Law 14/2006 of 26 May on assisted human reproduction techniques, if a series of requirements are met. In particular, Article 9 states that:
- Filiation cannot be legally determined nor can any legal effect or relationship be recognized between the child born through the application of the techniques regulated in this Law and the deceased husband when his reproductive material is not in the woman’s uterus on the date of the man’s death.
- Notwithstanding the provisions of the previous section, the husband may give his consent, in the document referred to in Article 6.3, in a public deed, will or advance directive document, for his reproductive material to be used within 12 months of his death to inseminate his wife. Such generation shall produce the legal effects that are derived from marital filiation. Consent to application of the techniques in such circumstances may be revoked at any time prior to their implementation.
- The consent referred to in the previous paragraph is presumed to have been granted when the spouse has undergone an assisted reproduction process already underway for the transfer of pre-embryos created prior to death of the husband.
The Law requires compliance with several requirements for posthumous fatherhood:
- The gametes have to be obtained before death and cryopreserved in a specialized clinic. In Spain, unlike the US, no sperm samples can be extracted post-mortem.
- Prior explicit consent on use of gametes in the event of death must be given by means of an informed consent document or through the will.
- The use of gametes is of short duration, from any time of death to a maximum of 12 months.
- The decedent’s gametes are subject to the same requirements and guarantees as those applicable to assisted reproduction processes in general.
Bioethical assessment
The procedures associated with assisted reproduction have facilitated the emergence of numerous controversial cases derived from the possibility of separating fatherhood and motherhood both with respect to the origin of the gametes used in fertilization, and of the sexual relationship itself, detaching them from the reproductive act and fostering anomalous situations. These include the production of embryos from unknown donors, the gestation by women of embryos obtained with oocytes (eggs) from their daughters or sperm from their sons, surrogacy where the surrogate mother agrees to give up her child after birth to the commissioning parents (who may or may not be the biological parents), or, as in this case, the use of sperm from a deceased man to conceive children after his death.
Human sexuality, which is designed towards complementary interpersonal relationships, and includes the possibility of being fertile by producing offspring, involves the acceptance of fatherhood and motherhood by those who responsibly welcome the life they generate. Accordingly, the child has the right not only to have parents who are responsible for their care and support, but also to know them, to discover their roots, and to identify the people who have given them life: their biological parents.
Conversely, parenthood does not constitute a right for parents: there is no right to a child. The child cannot be conceived for the sole purpose of satisfying a desire at any cost; rather, it must be its own good — the good of the child — that justifies its creation, gestation, birth and upbringing.
Furthermore, the best interests of the child, the weakest and most vulnerable in this process, demands that their rights and dignity be respected. The father and mother, who have established a unique human relationship, capable of transmitting life and taking responsibility for its care, are a right of the child, who identifies his origin in the family community where he was conceived. To dismiss it, depriving it of access to the parenthood from which it originates, is, in some way, to instrumentalize it to satisfy the desires of those who advocate these processes, through the use of gametes of anonymous embryos, surrogacy, the promotion of single-parent models where one of the parents is absent, and others in which the right of the child to parentage is threatened.
The state of orphanhood of a child who has lost one of its parents in any way creates an unexpected, unplanned situation in which the child will have to cope with this undesired absence. But knowingly planning that the child does not have access to father and mother figures, which it needed biologically to be conceived, producing embryos from gametes that do not belong to those who will undertake its care and upbringing (or even its gestation as in the case of surrogacy), is to deprive it of a basic right: the right to know and be welcomed by those who gave life to it.
Adoption is a noble gesture to grant those who have lost the possibility of being welcomed by their biological parents what they are entitled to: care, affection, support, and education. But it serves the need to restore to the child that to which he is entitled and which he has lost, because it constitutes his best interests.
The case at hand is different from this, where the needs of this child —- not being with his biological parents, those who conceived him — respond to a pre-designed artificial reproduction project, in which sexuality and reproduction, donation and fertility, biological parenthood and parenting are deliberately separated, depriving him of the right to his parents, in order to satisfy the interests of the promoters of these processes.
As we have previously reported, there are increasingly frequent cases in which children conceived with gametes from anonymous donors claim their right to know their biological parents, who constitute their origin, giving rise to numerous legal battles about the possibility of maintaining the anonymity of these donors (which was assured to them when they donated their gametes) or, depending on the best interests of the child, revealing their identity that the child has the right to know.
In this regard, the Spanish Bioethics Committee, an advisory body attached to the Ministry of Health, issued a report in 2020 recognizing the “right of the child born through assisted human reproduction techniques to know its biological origin above the right to donor anonymity”.
Fertilization with posthumous gametes definitively hinders the relationship that the child would have wanted to establish with its father or mother, from whom he comes and who gave him life.
Julio Tudela and Cristina Castillo
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia