The US Senate has rejected a Republican Party bill calling for medical care for babies who survive an abortion, as well as a ban on late-term abortions.
The “Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act” bill provided for criminal consequences for physicians who failed to care for a surviving baby after an abortion in a hospital and who failed to provide the same medical care as they would render to any other child born alive at the same gestational age.
The bill also called for a ban on abortions after 20 weeks, as this is when babies are supposed to be able to feel pain inside their mother’s womb.
It was introduced on January 16 by Louisiana, Oklahoma, and Indiana Republican Senators John Kennedy, James Lankford, and Jim Banks and co-sponsored by 39 other Republican Senators. The bill needed 60 votes to advance, but failed by a vote of 52 to 47.
Infanticide: Ethical debate and Peter Singer’s position
The debate on the perception of fetal pain and the protection of babies born alive after an abortion is intertwined with the controversial positions of the philosopher Peter Singer. Known for his utilitarian approach, he has defended infanticide in cases of severe disability, arguing that the life of a newborn does not have the same value as that of a conscious adult.
According to Singer, the ability to experience pleasure and avoid pain is what gives value to life, and in the absence of these capabilities, the life of a newborn could be considered less valuable.
Likewise, the Australian utilitarian philosopher argues that there is no significant ontological difference between a fetus and a newborn, and that both lack self-consciousness and the capacity to understand their existence over time. Therefore, from his perspective, infanticide in certain cases could be justified in a similar way to abortion.
Thus, eugenic infanticide is recurrent throughout history: Greece, Egypt, Rome, Carthage and even in China in the 1970s and in Ancient Sparta. Neither Singer nor the current promoters of infanticide are original in their eugenic approaches.
The unacceptable reductionism that entails linking human dignity and its inherent rights to the capacity for self-awareness, autonomy or the capacity to experience sensitivity, must be denounced and rejected outright from any anthropologically based bioethical reflection.
Individuals of the human species, whether in their immature form as embryos, unconscious in comatose states or dependent in cases of severe disability, must be considered people, possessors of dignity and rights, the first of which is the right to life.
Their exclusion from this category has allowed throughout history exterminations, genocides, eugenics, and violations of human rights by those who claim the right to grant or withdraw this dignity based on their arbitrary criteria.
Ending the life of an immature embryo with only a few cells is no less serious than doing so with a 38-week-old fetus, a newborn or an incurably ill person. Just as ending the life of a disabled person is just as serious as ending the life of a healthy individual.
The current permissiveness towards infanticide in the case of babies who survive attempted abortions shows in a heartbreaking way the sinister face of abortion.
The current permissiveness in the face of infanticide in the case of babies who have survived abortions shows, in a heartbreaking way, the sinister face of abortion.
Letting a neonate who has survived an attempted abortion die is equivalent to a double murder, inappropriate for those who claim for themselves the respect for their rights that they deny to others.
Julio Tudela and Cristina Castillo
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia
References:
1. Müller, F., O´Rahilly, R. “The amygdaloid complex and the medial and lateral ventricular eminences in staged human embryos”. J Anat. 2006; 208 (5): 547–564.
2. Anand, K. J. S., Hickey, P. R. “Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus”. New England Journal of Medicine. 1987; 317: 1321-29.
3. Tadros, M. A., Lim, R., Hughes, D. I., Brichta, A. M., Callister, R. J. “Electrical maturation of spinal neurons in the human fetus: comparison of ventral and dorsal horn”. J Neurophysiol. 2015; 114 (5): 2661-71.