A recent experiment published in the journal Cell Stem Cell reveals how scientists generated mice using the genetic input of sperm from two fathers. However, it should be clarified that oocytes from female mice were also used to obtain them.
Haploid embryonic stem cells were obtained by fertilizing a previously enucleated oocyte with a sperm. After being genetically modified, these were injected with a new sperm from a second male, obtaining pluripotent cells with genetic material from two sperm. These cells were then introduced into a tetraploid embryo, i.e., an embryo with a double genetic endowment, which was transferred to a female for gestation.
We offer an analysis of this case, delving into the complexity of this type of research, as well as its future prospects.
The genomes of each of the parental gametes in higher mammals have differences in genomic imprinting. These are epigenetic marks in specific domains of the genome consisting of differences in DNA methylation or other epigenetic mechanisms.
Imprinting is acquired depending on the sex from which each gamete originates. There are differences in regions of the genome of eggs and sperm, which occur before or during their formation in the process of maternal or paternal gametogenesis, respectively. Experiments with mammalian embryos have demonstrated that, for fertilization to occur, their gametic nuclei must be derived from two different-sex parents, male and female. The biological basis for this lies in the important role played by diversity in enabling species to thrive. Previous experiments with mouse embryos had demonstrated the non-viability of embryos artificially constituted with two female nuclei or two male nuclei due to imprinting differences in their genomes [1]. The alleles of the imprinted genes remain in the adult somatic cells, with their two maternal or paternal epigenetic states, so that the expression of a certain allele is favored over the other depending on its parental origin.
In the biological cycle of higher vertebrates, differentiation of the genital organs does not begin until several weeks have passed, after gastrulation has been completed and organogenesis has begun, which in humans occurs from week 7. The development of ovaries or testis from an undifferentiated gonad is directed depending on the presence or absence of the SRY gene in females or males, respectively. This testis-determining gene is located on the Y chromosome. Everything is aimed at the necessary existence of two sexes in sexually-reproducing organisms, the basis of the diversity required for the continuity of the species.
After the appearance of germline tissue, the “oogenesis” or female gametogenesis that will generate the eggs begins early, during the first few months of female fetal development, but is not completed. In mammalian females, the stem cells of the future eggs halt the “meiosis” process in the prophase of the first meiotic division, in a state called “dictyotene“, and remain so until they reach sexual maturity at puberty. “Maternal imprinting” occurs when meiosis resumes and oogenesis is completed to give rise to an egg in each menstrual cycle [2].
In contrast, on the male side, the primordial cells of the male germline acquire the paternal imprint as early as in the embryonic-fetal stage, with the methylation of specific regions different from those of the maternal imprint. Accordingly, this takes place long before reaching male sexual maturity. Therefore, maternal and paternal imprints are acquired out of phase during development in both sexes. After fertilization, when the organs are constituted in the adult phase, the genes are marked and, of the two alleles, only one (the paternal or maternal) will be expressed, since the other is inactivated by methylation or epigenetic alteration that turns off its expression.
Stem cell-induced gametogenesis
The process described thus far is what happens in natural conditions. However, for various reasons of an applied nature, some researchers have set out to obtain human gamete-like cells, eggs, and sperm in the laboratory from cells of other tissues of the individual him- or herself. Their aim is to obtain “artificial gametes”, or “gamete-like cells” from embryonic stem cells (from blastocyst stage-embryos), adult stem cells from germline tissues or others, induced pluripotent cells derived from somatic cells using the Yamanaka genetic reprogramming method [3], or other sources. These would be cells that do not originate from natural female or male gametogenesis, although they would have a haploid number of chromosomes. It is evident that generating gamete-like cells from cells with imprinted genomic regions can lead to viability problems for individuals that are formed from them.
This type of research has a number of points of interest. On the one hand, there is the idea of its use to obtain embryos by in vitro fertilization (IVF), both for basic research, as well as to gain insight into the mechanisms of maternal and paternal imprinting and their influence on organ development. They are also of interest in the creation of animal models to study gene therapy and, likewise, embryonic models (human embryoids), and for clinical applications, cell therapies, regenerative medicine, xenogeneic transplants, or to satisfy reproductive desires even when there are no infertility issues.
Artificial gametes would also pave the way to understanding the complex process of human gametogenesis and facilitate the study of infertility and the causes of some hereditary disorders. In addition, artificial gametes, if obtained, would be offered for other applications for same-sex couples, single individuals, or fertile couples at risk of transmitting serious diseases to their progeny.
In this sense, expectations to date had been technically better with female compared to male artificial gametes. A precursor to this idea is the achievement of Japanese researchers, who used both embryonic stem cells and induced pluripotent stem cells from female mice to induce epiblast-like cells (epiLCs). These were then aggregated with gonadal embryonic somatic cells to induce the development of germline cells, capable of reconstituting ovaries in vitro. These “artificial ovaries” were subsequently transplanted into female mice to stimulate oogenesis. The ovaries were able to produce eggs, which after harvesting and use in IVF, produced viable embryos [4].
Thus, an important advance was achieved in “bi-maternal” reproduction (from two eggs) in mice, by targeting certain key regions involved in maternal imprinting, through epigenetic coding.
The attempt to create bi-paternal mice from two sperm has already been the subject of analysis in an article published on the Bioethics Observatory website. However, the main issues with this type of induced gametic cells are, on the one hand, the erasure of epigenetic modifications and, on the other, the difficulty of establishing marks in them similar to those that determine the maternal or paternal imprint of natural gametes. Added to this is the ever-present risk of possible epigenetic alterations due to the conditions of cell manipulation in vitro.
One more step in the manipulation of sexual reproduction
Now, in February 2025, a new study on obtaining bi-paternal mice has just been published by a group of researchers led by Wei Li and colleagues from the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing. The sperm were injected into a previously enucleated egg (nuclear transplant method). The mice went on to develop into adulthood, although the offspring exhibited multiple developmental abnormalities, such as edema, organ enlargement, and partial neonatal lethality due to breathing and feeding difficulties. Bi-paternal mice that reached adulthood were unable to reproduce naturally and required cloning for propagation.
The question posed by the researchers was whether the genes involved in imprinting were the cause of the abnormalities and whether they pose a barrier to bi-paternal reproduction in mammals. In their study, they explored various imprinting correction strategies in the genomes of the sperm used, including frameshift mutations, deletions or deletion of part of the DNA sequence of genes involved in imprinting, and regulatory region edits. After modifying up to 20 regions of the genome involved in imprinting, they concluded that maternal or paternal imprinting is the main barrier to unisexual reproduction in mammals and the factor that limits the pluripotent potential of embryonic stem cells and induced pluripotent cells [5].
These observations underscore the role of genes involved in imprinting throughout development and advocate the need for further research to uncover the causes of developmental abnormalities in bi-parental individuals and to discover new therapeutic strategies for imprinting-related disorders.
Bioethical assessment
It seems obvious that this study developed in animal models allows us to learn about the mechanisms that determine or limit sexual reproduction, and is of basic interest to better understand the genetic factors that determine sexual differentiation, although the results obtained thus far have been poor. Nevertheless, it is unethical to promote the artificial synthesis of gametes to be used in human reproduction in combination with IVF, nuclear transplantation in enucleated oocytes, or other technologies for the conception of human beings, due to lack of safety and respect for the human genetic heritage.
There are safety problems due to the risk of uncontrolled epigenetic alterations, such as those produced in the experiments with mice, or even due to the artificiality of an immature methodology. Furthermore, their application for reproductive purposes causes problems related to the use of bi-paternal or bi-maternal individuals in order to satisfy the wish to have a child with a desired genetic profile, something that goes against morality because it implies the imposition of a genetic profile on a human being, similar to eugenic and neoeugenic practices. In the words of the German philosopher and sociologist Jürgen Habermas (b. 1929) on eugenic manipulation, these types of practices upset our ethical understanding of the human species, since by subjecting manipulated individuals to the contentious practice of “objectification”, the full authorship of their own life story is ruptured, consequently diminishing the personal autonomy that we mutually recognize as the basis of the dignity and equality of human beings.
Nicolás Jouve
Professor Emeritus of Genetics at the University of Alcalá
Member of the Bioethics Observatory
References:
[1] Z–K. Li et al., “Generation of bimaternal and bipaternal mice from hypomethylated haploid ESCs with imprinting region deletions”. Cell Stem Cell, 23 (5) (2018) 665–676.
[2] O Y. Bata, T. Kono, “Maternal primary imprinting is established at a specific time for each gene throughout oocyte growth”. J. Biol. Chem. 277 (2002) 5285–5289.
[3] K. Takahashi – S. Yamanaka, “Induction of pluripotent Stem Cells from Mouse Embryonic and Adult Fibroblast Cultures by Defined Factors” Cell 126 (4) (2006) 663-676.
[4] K. Hayashi, K. et al., “Offspring from oocytes Derived from in vitro primordial Germ Cell-like Cells in Mice”. Science. 338 (6109) (2012) 971-975.
[5] Zhi-kun Li, Wei Li et al. “Adult bi-paternal offspring generated through direct modification of imprinted genes in mammals”. Cell Stem Cell. 32 (2025) 1–14.
