A recent study analyzes the surplus of cryopreserved human embryos surplus from in vitro fertilization techniques stored in the United Kingdom.
According to this research, their number is the highest since records began in 1991 by the UK Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA).
The paper presents a quantitative analysis of the data from 1991 to 2019 provided by the HFEA, as well as a comment on the trends observed within this data, which show that, at least, 130,000 human embryos that remained cryopreserved have been discarded in the Kingdom United since 1991.
Currently, 500,000 of these human embryos remain frozen in liquid nitrogen tanks, most of them destined for destruction.
The unfortunate Warnock Report, published in 1984, defined the “pre-embryo” as an embryo less than 14 days old. Despite this, it attributed a special moral status to it by preventing its direct elimination in cases of supernumerary embryos obtained by IVF that are not going to be implanted in the uterus of their mothers.
The scientific evidence available today has shown that the term “pre-embryo” lacks scientific foundation, given that there is no change in nature in the early embryo that allows us to speak of different entities depending on the maturational state.
The confirmation of the implementation of a developmental program marked by the genetic information of the embryo itself and the epigenetic evolution that accompanies it, makes it possible to identify the existence of an individual of the human species from the moment of fertilization.
Attributing a different status – the “pre-embryo” – depending on the moment of maturation, as the Warnock Commission did, is arbitrary and indefensible based on the scientific evidence available today.
The contradiction arises when laws protect embryos produced by assisted reproductive techniques, limiting their direct destruction, and yet free abortion has been normalized in many countries. In these countries there is no requirement to safeguard the rights of aborted embryos, unlike embryos produced in vitro, which should be treated differently.
This insurmountable contradiction shows the utilitarian background that promotes contempt for human life in its most unprotected and dependent form.
It is bioethically unacceptable to end human lives through induced abortion, but it is no less unacceptable to generate enormous quantities of embryos destined mostly for destruction as a consequence of in vitro fertilization. According to the aforementioned article, “only 8% of the interviewed families intended to make further pregnancy attempts with their surplus embryos after one year”.
Alarms over the accumulation of cryopreserved human embryos have failed to reverse this tragic trend. The millions of embryonic human beings stored in liquid nitrogen freezers awaiting the moment of their destruction continue to increase.
Attempts to limit the number of embryos obtained in these techniques clash with the interests of the clinics involved, which aim to increase their success rates by obtaining more embryos, on which their business largely depends.
The new possibilities of preimplantation genetic diagnosis techniques make it possible to select the best specimens from a multitude of embryos, in a eugenic exercise that aggravates the problem.
Since the birth of Louise Brown in 1978, assisted reproduction has not ceased to generate controversy: thousands of discarded embryos, designer babies, tanks full of frozen embryos, 60-year-old women who decide to be mothers, surrogacy, research with embryos…
Something is not working, but it does not seem to matter to the population, which continues to resort to assisted reproduction techniques in increasing numbers, with our country in the lead.
Julio Tudela
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia