The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) has published a statement by its Chief Executive, Peter Thompson, in which he recommends that the British government extend the time limit on embryo research.

The current limit generally established for research on human embryos is set at 14 days after fertilization. This limit was established in the late 1970s, after the birth of the first baby conceived by in vitro fertilization, Louise Brown, in 1978.

On 4 May 1979, the Ethics Advisory Board (EAB) of the Department of Health, Education and Welfare published in a report that the human embryo in its first fourteen days was only a developing human life form. Moreover, with a high risk of mortality and lacking individuality.

According to this committee, in this period no defined status could be assigned to it and thus the report left the door open to the practice of scientific research with embryonic material, the destruction of which would not present a major ethical conflict.

Subsequently, in 1984, the Warnock Commission [1] issued a new report from the United Kingdom, which laid the foundations for the acceptability of embryo research. It confirmed the arbitrary 14-day period from conception, adopting the previous conclusions of the American EAB, in which the embryo would lack individual nature.

One embryologist on the committee, Dr. Anne McLaren, went so far as to claim that there was no human life before the appearance of the primitive streak in the trophoblast, around day 14 from conception.

The concept of “pre-embryo” is based on these assumptions, understood as the embryo formed in vitro by the group of cells resulting from the progressive division of the oocyte from the time it is fertilized until 14 days later.

Is the human embryo an individual of the species?

Scientific advances in embryology have accumulated evidence about the nature of early human embryos. They offer certain proof of the existence of an individual of the human species from the moment of fertilization of the oocyte by the sperm.

The genetic identity of the early embryo (“pre-embryo”) rules out the lack of its own individuality as was claimed. Epigenetic processes mark the start of a continuous development program of increasing complexity, embryonic proteomics, the position information of cell lines is differentiating, organizing and positioning from the earliest stages of development.

The current scientific consensus on the existence of an individual of the human species from fertilization is overwhelming. Proof of this is the ruling of the European Court of Justice in October 2011, which recognized that “any human ovum must, as soon as fertilised, be regarded as a ‘human embryo’”. “That classification must also apply to a non-fertilised human ovum into which the cell nucleus from a mature human cell has been transplanted”.

However, although the concept of pre-embryo has been abandoned in the scientific world, the treatment given to it based on this consideration has not. Its right to life has remained unprotected given the permissiveness for its instrumentalization and destruction in the field of scientific research.

The premises that allowed this lack of protection in the 1980s have now proved to be false. However, the attacks on the dignity of these early embryos continue as if nothing had changed: the confirmation of their individual nature has not been translated into a recognition of their dignity and rights.

More time for human embryo research

The move to extend the arbitrary 14-day period to research with more developed embryos will likely lead to more related research, which means more embryo destruction.

The reasons given by Peter Thompson from the HFEA refer to significant scientific advances in these lines of research that “could provide valuable information, in a strictly regulated environment, to enable research for specific purposes that are already set out in the law.”

Utilitarianism vs. Personalism

The application of utilitarian bioethical criteria, based exclusively on the expected results, favors the generalization in the clinical and research field of procedures that may violate the dignity and rights of individuals, especially the most vulnerable.

Immature human beings or those with chronic and incurable illnesses are victims of these approaches, with the discarding of embryos, abortion or euthanasia.

A diametrically opposed bioethical perspective is offered by Personalism, which places human dignity and life as goods that must be defended in all circumstances and in all individuals, regardless of their characteristics or maturity.

Attempts to promote scientific research based on the violation of human rights, the first of which is the right to life, have historically been counterproductive. To continue to ignore this is to betray science and human progress.

Julio Tudela

Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences

Catholic University of Valencia

 

[1] Great Britain. Department of Health and Social Security. Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilization and Embryology, Chair Dame Mary Warnock. Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilization and Embryology, London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. 1984.

 

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!