The birth of a baby after 31 years of embryonic cryopreservation highlights the bioethical dilemma posed by thousands of human embryos left over from in vitro fertilization techniques that remain indefinitely frozen in centers around the world.
This extraordinary case, in which an American couple adopted an embryo conceived in 1994 by Linda Archerd and her former husband, illustrates the technological possibilities of long-term cryopreservation. It also illustrates the urgent need to ethically address the fate of these living members of the human species.
Their only alternative for survival in the face of their biological parents’ renunciation is embryo adoption, a procedure that saves lives but raises bioethical concerns.
A baby conceived 31 years ago through in vitro fertilization was born last July in the United States, after remaining frozen in an embryonic state for more than three decades. According to MIT Technology Review, the newborn was implanted in a woman named Lindsey, who, along with her husband Tim, decided to adopt him through embryo adoption.
The embryo genetically belongs to Linda Archerd and her then-husband who obtained it through assisted reproduction techniques along with three other embryos in 1994.
At that time, the couple used one of the embryos to have a daughter, while the remaining three were cryopreserved.
Maintenance for decades
When she started going through menopause, she decided to look for adoptive parents for the remaining embryos.
This alternative is one of three options under US law for surplus embryos from assisted fertility procedures: third-party adoption, donation for scientific research, or destruction.
Background of the procedure
Cases of embryo adoption, although rare, are not a novelty in the field of reproductive medicine.
These types of procedures have been previously documented, although the present case stands out due to the extensive cryopreservation period that elapsed before birth.
Bioethical assessment
The drama of surplus embryos from in vitro fertilization cycles that remain cryopreserved with an uncertain fate reveals the most worrying side of assisted reproduction techniques.
The long-term viability of these embryos demonstrates that they are living individuals of the human species and not simple cellular aggregates or biological remains.
The biological parents’ decision to renounce the gestation of these embryos is morally unacceptable, and adoption by other couples is their only chance of survival.
However, there has been ethical reservation about this adoption, as it might somehow validate the continued production and preservation of surplus embryos.
Only a reformulation of the application of assisted reproduction techniques could help avoid the tragedy of the hundreds of thousands of human embryos that remain cryopreserved, awaiting destruction in most cases.
Julio Tudela and Cristina Castillo
Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences
Catholic University of Valencia