What experimental science says about the human embryo is fundamental”
Thus begins an article published in Spanish newspaper “El País” a few weeks ago on 26 May, entitled Scientists seek to conduct research on embryos older than 14 days in order to understand the “most important” moment in human development: “According to a panel of scientists, it [the embryo] starts to become an individual at 14 days of age when the primitive streak is formed, which is the point after which it is impossible for that “jumble” of cells to divide to form twins”, read also the article published in Science Daily, March 4, 2021.
These claims do not conform to the reality of what science has been demonstrating for several decades, with a growing body of experimental evidence (read Human embryos biological status). We are again faced with an attempt to manipulate the reality of the human being in its initial stage. For Biology, however, an embryo is not an abstract entity, but the first stage in the development of life after fertilization.
Minimizing the significance of the embryo can have only one aim, which those who constitute the aforementioned panel of scientists do not conceal: To justify the use of embryos obtained by in vitro fertilization for research purposes, even going so far as to demand the lifting of laws imposing restrictions on the use of embryos older than 14 days derived from these procedures.
Can the desire to use embryos change the true nature of human lives from fertilization?
Clearly not. In terms of the status of the embryo, everything has been done for expediency, even going so far as the absurdity of doubting that it is a living entity of our species and, consequently, whether it is to be accorded an intrinsic moral value and therefore whether it is to be protected. What science says about the human embryo is fundamental, because we could hardly confer on the concept of person the dignity they deserve, and the recognition of their intrinsic value because of their dignity, to something whose human biological nature is disregarded. If a priority were to be established, the first word would be the evidence of science and the last would be the legal approximation, passing through anthropology and ethics which, depending on the biological nature, dignity and ethical value accorded to the embryo, should provide for the protection applicable to it as a human biological entity. Nevertheless, the debate has not followed this order. From a utilitarian perspective especially, the discussion has been muddied by taking it to a terrain that is more speculative or deliberative than real; it ignores the biological nature and intrinsic value of human life at its most vulnerable stage, by distorting the evidence of science and imposing laws beyond what science says about what an embryo is, in order to facilitate its use in research that could well be carried out on animal embryos.
In many countries — and in Spain in particular — the illogicality of the disregard of life in its initial stage is clear. Anything goes to justify the instrumentalization of embryos obtained by in vitro fertilization. Spanish laws (law 14/2006 on Assisted Human Reproduction and law 14/2007 on Biomedical Research) go so far as to call embryos obtained by in vitro fertilization “pre-embryos” – a word that does not exist in biology, and that is currently ruled out by the scientific community. It is proof of the attempt to diminish the biological reality of human lives and justify their manipulation, incidentally circumventing the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, or the Oviedo Convention, adopted at the request of the Council of Europe in Oviedo on 4 April 1997, ratified and signed by Spain in 1999, which states very clearly in Art. 18: “Where the law allows research on embryos in vitro, it shall ensure adequate protection of the embryo […]. The creation of human embryos for research purposes is prohibited”.
Is the embryo living entity a human life?
To base the consideration that human life only has an entity from a given moment is a manipulation. To say that that point is when it reaches individuality is really just a shrewd idea that pursues an end. On the basis of this idea, human life begins to have an entity when twins will no longer form from an embryo. According to a widespread but never proven belief, this circumstance can occur at any time within 14 days of fertilization, i.e. until gastrulation. This is when the “primitive streak” is formed in the embryo, a band of thickened cells located in the posterior central region of the embryo overlying the three embryonic cell layers: ectoderm, mesoderm and endoderm.
But the reality is much simpler. Twinning is an accidental event that has a probability of less than 0.2%; the only thing it demonstrates is that the “individuality” of the initial embryo does not imply indivisibility. Starting at fertilization there is a real entity, a biological reality that will be unique in 99.8% of cases. Splitting and separation to restart the path of development as if they were different embryos is a rare event that can take place long before gastrulation, even from the beginning of development, but it does not mean that what has been up to then is not a human ontological reality.
A tribute to Dr. Gonzalo Herranz, Father of medical Ethics in Spain
I would like to take this opportunity to pay tribute to Dr. Gonzalo Herranz (1931-2021), one of the great pioneers of Bioethics and Medical Ethics and father of Medical Ethics in Spain, professor and director of the Department of Biomedical Humanities at the University of Navarre for many years, who sadly died on 20 May. Professor Herranz strongly argued that twinning was possible as late as 14 days after fertilization. In an article published in the journal Zygote, Dr. Herranz discussed the unproven and more theoretical models based on experimental demonstrations, according to which monozygotic twins originate from late splitting of embryos [1]. In his excellent argument, the Professor suggested that this event could happen even within the process of fertilization due to an alteration in the transition from the zygote to the two daughter cells or “blastomeres”. If these cells separated as soon as the first cleavage division was completed, they would result in two genetically identical twins that, from the beginning, would have their own trophoblast from which their own protective membranes would be derived. In fact, according to statistics, dichorionic (DC) and diamniotic (DA), twins account for 25% to 30% of monozygotic twins.
Embryo living entity, delaying the consideration as human beings would leave the possibility of using embryos for research in the hands of interested parties
In a long and thorough analysis of the experiments and the main biological arguments used in the debates on the issue of twinning, Dr. Herranz expanded his claim in a masterful work he published in 2013, entitled The Fictitious Embryo. A Critical History of a Biological Myth [2]. In his book, he reviewed everything that had been put forward, to conclude that such arguments are not only flimsy and do not prove what they claim, but that, as a whole, they constitute a perfect example of how ignorance of biological data necessarily leads to meretricious bioethics. Worse still, it was exposed how scientific data can be manipulated to justify any interest. In this case, delaying the consideration of human beings would leave the possibility of using embryos for research in the hands of interested parties, which is what it was about. It is a paradigmatic example of utilitarian bioethics.
” […] gastrulation is merely one more stage in the organized evolution of the embryo according to its development program, increasingly complex and uninterrupted until death of the individual […]”
The biological approach of embryo living entity
But, the facts are as they are, not as one wants them to be. And the main biological facts proven in relation to the beginning of human life are as follows:
· Fertilization marks the beginning of a new human life, because it is when the most important biological characteristic is constituted: the “genetic identity”, which is preserved throughout life until death: “The first significant moment is fertilization, understood as the fusion of the pronuclei of the sperm and the egg. A new biological entity emerges here, which possesses the genetic endowment characteristic of the human species” (Spanish Bioethics Committee 2 June 2014, report on the Draft Organic Law on the Protection of the Life of the Conceived and the Rights of Pregnant Women).
· The zygote is the first physical reality of a new human life.
· An embryo is not a “jumble” of cells, but an organized entity, an organism that follows a program of continuous development beginning at fertilization.
· Cell Biology and Developmental Genetics explain that each cell of the embryo, from the first cleavage division of the zygote, plays a role in interaction with the whole.
· What marks the stages in the development of a new human life in its embryonic (up to the eighth week) and fetal (from the ninth week) phases is the successive and programmed expression of the genes that came together at the time the gamete cells merged to form the zygote. The embryo is a unit of development in itself that assembles itself with the genetic program that was set in the zygote.
· The embryo that develops is always the same organism, and if its DNA is human, it is unquestionably a human life.
· Development is a dynamic and “continuous” process, and while new features gradually emerge, it would be arbitrary to determine a specific time to decide at what point in embryonic development there are enough features to concede the status of a human being.
· The early embryo could be potentially divisible, but it remains a stage in the biological cycle that began after fertilization. The embryo, divisible or not, is already a human life that possesses its unchanging identity “for life” on which its development as a biological entity depends.
· Every life is a whole integrated into its two dimensions: space and time. It is just as wrong to consider human life only in relation to one of its stages, downplaying or denying the reality of the existence of the others, as it is to seek to reduce it to a mere cluster of unrelated parts.
· In the human case, the complexity of development increases until it becomes an organism with billions of specialized cells divided into over 220 different cell types. It is, from fertilization, the same organism, that lives its life until death.
Conclusion
Finally, it is also incorrect to say that for developmental biologists, the most important moment in a person’s life is not when they are born, or when they have children, or when they die, but when the gastrula is formed. It is true that, after nesting, towards the third week, the phase characterized by the appearance of the “primitive streak” begins. With gastrulation, the general plan of the body is defined and organogenesis begins, but, as it is the same life throughout the process, before and after, they are equally important. Moreover, this gastrulation is merely one more stage in the organized evolution of the embryo according to its development program, increasingly complex and uninterrupted until the death of the individual.
It is absurd to say that life begins on the fourteenth day, when everything that will happen from that moment is genetically determined from the first day.
Nicolás Jouve, Professor Emeritus of Genetics.
Chairman of CiViCa and member of the Spanish Bioethics Committee.
References
[1] G. Herranz. «The timing of monozygotic twinning: a criticism of the common model». Zygote (2013): 1-14, doi:10.1017/S0967199413000257 [2] G. Herranz, El embrión ficticio: historia de un mito biológico. Ed. Palabra, Madrid, 2013.