In the trial, which took place in Virginia, a cancer survivor sued her ex-husband because she wanted the sole ownership of the two embryos they had frozen after an IVF cycle or divide them as jointly owned personal property.

The woman, who has a daughter with her ex-husband, argued that implanting the embryos they froze in 2015, when they were still married, was her last chance to become a mother.

The couple separated in 2017 and in 2018 agreed that neither of them would remove the embryos from the IVF clinic’s storage.

After the divorce, in 2019, the ex-wife asked her ex-husband for permission to implant the embryos, which he refused, arguing that he did not want to become a father again.

In 2020, she filed a motion to determine the ownership of cryopreserved human embryos, in which she sought sole possession of the embryos. When she was unsuccessful, she filed for a partition of the embryos’ ownership, arguing that the parties could not agree on their disposition, but her motion was unsuccessful.

In 2021, she filed another partition lawsuit, which was also dismissed.

In 2023 she filed a claim for partition of the frozen embryos, in which she requested ownership of both embryos for herself, although she would also agree to keep only one.

Finally, the judge dismissed the partition claim with prejudice, as “the Court finds that the human embryos at issue in this matter are not goods or chattels subject to partition under the Virginia partition statutes.”

Bioethical Assessment

Assisted reproduction techniques raise conflicting issues related to paternity, filiation, and respect for the dignity of human beings who, in embryonic and cryopreserved states, can be claimed as objects of desire, as is the case here.

The multiple possibilities offered by these techniques mean that gametes from the parents or donors are available, which can represent a threat to their children, who may one day demand to know the identity of their biological parents.

To the above assumptions, we should add the case of surrogacy, which complicates the situation with the presence of a surrogate mother whose identity may also be requested in the future by the child.

The instrumentalization of reproduction tends to turn the child into an object of desire, rather than a good in itself. This justifies generating multiple embryos in order to obtain a valid one, discarding or freezing the surplus, or dissociating biological paternity and maternity from gestation, as in the case of surrogacy.

The reasonable desire for parenthood does not justify any intervention to achieve it, because the dignity of the child himself, his right to a family, and the desirability of knowing his origins establish the limits for achieving this desire.

In the case at hand, the cryopreserved embryos of a divorced couple are claimed as apparent disputed property and subjected to an inadmissible objection, which the court has rejected.

But the tragedy remains unresolved: if the embryos are not gestated, they will remain frozen indefinitely unless they are transferred to other couples or used as experimental material, which would result in their destruction.

Faced with the tragedy of the millions of human embryos that remain cryopreserved, there seems to be no solution. They are generated through assisted reproduction techniques, and in most cases their future is destruction or abandonment in storage at -196°C.

Julio Tudela and Ester Bosch

Bioethics Observatory – Institute of Life Sciences

Catholic Univesity of Valencia

 

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!